Follower Count Doesn’t Matter as Much as You Think
Here’s what to focus on instead if you want your content to work for your business.
Chasing followers instead of building an email list keeps your business stuck in vanity metrics, but when you shift from email list vs social media followers and focus on capturing and nurturing the right audience, you create consistent engagement, clear positioning, and predictable revenue.
It’s Not About Follower Count
Email > Social
Real Connection Comes from Real Content
What to Do if You’re Just Getting Started
You Don’t Need a Massive List. You Need the Right System.
It's Not About Follower Count
The rules keep changing.
Instagram reach declined 12 percent year over year, reinforcing why the email list vs social media followers conversation matters for long-term growth.
Source: Socialinsider, May 2024 to May 2025
Platforms tell you what to do so your content reaches more people. You follow the advice. Then the algorithm shifts. So you adjust. Then it shifts again.
You can post consistently and still reach only a fraction of your followers.
After a while, it starts to feel personal.
Maybe you are not posting enough. Maybe your hooks are not strong enough. Maybe you need better lighting, better editing, better timing. You keep putting energy into content that may or may not reach people who never asked to hear from you in the first place.
It is hard to build momentum when the ground keeps moving.
And beneath all of it is a deeper issue.
When your growth strategy revolves around follower count instead of subscriber count, your audience lives on platforms you do not control. Access to them depends on algorithms, policy updates, and shifting priorities that have nothing to do with your business.
In the email list vs social media followers conversation, this is the tension most founders feel but struggle to name.
You are investing time into building reach, but you do not fully own the relationship.
Email > Social
Social media platforms are constantly changing. Algorithms shift. Ownership changes. What works today might tank tomorrow. You’re essentially building a brand on borrowed land.
Social media platforms are constantly changing. Algorithms shift. Ownership changes. What works today might tank tomorrow. You’re essentially building a brand on borrowed land.
Your email list? That’s yours.
You control when and how you show up. You’re not competing with a million other posts for 1.5 seconds of attention.
And I say this not just as someone who’s sent a few email newsletters—I’m a Mailchimp Pro Partner, and I’ve helped many businesses build email systems that consistently outperform their social media channels.
Because when someone signs up for your list, they’re raising their hand and saying:
I trust you
I want to hear from you
I’m interested in what you offer
That’s a deeper level of engagement—and it’s where long-term growth starts.
Real Connection Comes From Real Content
“I don’t have a massive following—but I’ve broken my revenue goals in three of the past four years by focusing on clear strategy, consistent content, and giving my audience something they can actually use.”
I’ve built Downstage Media with a relatively small audience. I don’t have a massive social following. But I’ve got a clear strategy, a strong message, and a consistent content system. Oh, and I’ve broken my revenue goals the past three out of four years.
That system focuses on giving my audience something they can actually use—something helpful, informational, or entertaining.
Every blog post, every email, every caption is created with the same goal in mind: Put you (not me) in your best light and help you move one step closer to a result you want.
It’s not about volume. It’s about value (and no, I don’t mean vague “add value” statements—I mean: give people something useful and relevant).
What to Do If You're Just Getting Started
If you’re still figuring out how to grow your audience or build an email list, start here:
1. Offer a lead magnet.
Give people something they want—a PDF, checklist, short video, whatever works for your audience. Make sure it solves a real problem or answers a question they’ve already asked.
2. Make it easy to find.
Don’t bury your opt-in at the bottom of your website. Put it on your homepage, in blog posts, and on social. Make it obvious and compelling.
3. Set up a welcome sequence.
Even 2–3 emails is enough to introduce yourself, offer a helpful resource, and invite them to take the next step.
4. Keep it simple and consistent.
You don’t need to email every day. But you do need to stay top of mind. Weekly or biweekly is plenty. Most of my clients (and me, TBH) think every two weeks is a good cadence.
Overwhelmed by Marketing? Use This 3-Stage Strategy to Drive Results FastYou Don’t Need a Massive List. You Need the Right System.
What’s going to grow your business isn’t viral reach. It’s clear messaging, repeatable content, and a system you can stick with.
That’s exactly what we build inside the Small Group Marketing Cohort.
It’s where business owners come to get focused, supported, and consistent with their content.
If you’re tired of trying to do it all alone—or you’re ready to stop guessing and start building something that lasts—this is your next step.
Ready to stop chasing followers and start growing a business?
Join the Small Group Marketing Cohort and let’s build your content engine—together.
Annie Figenshu
Annie Figenshu is keenly aware that many companies are pressed for time, and every minute counts. She helps brands make the most of their content marketing so that their hard work is shared with the world. Annie is certified in both StoryBrand and Mailchimp, has two kids with Beatles-themed names, and is afraid to think what a day without coffee would look like.